Thanks for the info. I'll let you know how it went when I return.

Based on TripAdvisor reviews, I booked a spearfishing/boating day with Swashbucklin' Tours. Just wondering if anyone here had any experience with them. It's a "build your own itinerary" tour and I'm trying to figure out what would be the best activities for us to pick.

Thanks for all the tips. I contacted one company to reserve a dinghy in advance, but they had a 48 hour "rain or shine" cancellation policy, so I'll wait til I get there to rent a dinghy.

Good afternoon. This is my first post to these forums. My husband and I, and another couple, are traveling to St. John from 1/29 - 2/4/12. I had actually planned a Dinghy Day, so this topic interested me. For those who have done this in the past, do you need reservations, or do you just show up at t...