And I should clarify one more thing. We will probably only use the rental car 2 out of 6 days in STT (1 day in STJ, 1 day touring around STT). So most of the time it will sit in the garage at Sugar Bay. Well, we'll also need it to and from the airport. But that is enough for me, given the car seats,...

I've read through a lot of the existing posts on this forum, but still can't decide based on our circumstances: Should we rent a car in St. Thomas? We are staying at Sugar Bay, doing the all inclusive. Thus, we do not HAVE to leave the property. But we want to: we want to take a day trip to St Johns...